Whistling In The Dark?

Think about a two- or three-year-old lying in a dim bedroom. Two things are happening at once. Their eyes aren't great at picking out objects in low light, and their imagination is running at full tilt. Kids that age will tell you, with complete conviction, that they hear or see something that exists nowhere but inside their own heads. Put those together and a shape in the corner becomes a monster. The parent comes in, says it isn't real, says go back to sleep and pretend it isn't there. The child hears that and complies, but notice what has actually happened: the monster is still there to them. They've just been instructed to behave as though it isn't.

Lying down changes everything about how a room looks. A child in bed is seeing the space from an angle they never use when they're sitting up or walking around. There's a developmental idea called object permanence, the point at which a kid can view something like a bottle from several sides, under different kinds of light, and still register it as the same bottle and handle it accordingly. A dark bedroom strips away most of the cues that make that recognition easy.

The eye itself adds to the problem. In bright light the cones, packed into the center of the retina, hand you a crisp picture in full color. In dim light you're relying on the rods, which deliver something closer to a blurry black-and-white image. Black-and-white photos and movies have mostly disappeared from daily life, so younger kids barely encounter that washed-out, edgeless look anywhere except the dark. I wonder whether that's part of where the fear of sleeping in the dark comes from. And then a parent tops it off by telling the child that what they're seeing is wrong, that how they perceive the shape is mistaken, that the fear is silly and should be shoved aside. Usually this is so the parent can relax and get back to sleep, satisfied they've chased the monsters off. They haven't. The child still believes the monsters are there. What's changed is that the people they'd normally turn to for protection now say there's nothing to protect against, so the kid is left to face the thing alone, probably in the dark, with no light reaching those scary corners.

So don't ask children to deny what they feel. The feelings don't vanish; they just go underground. You have to look at the room from where the child is. Mommy, daddy, the monster is right there, that's his head, those are his eyes, those are his hands, and look, claws. See, he's breathing. A fuzzy shape in near-darkness really can look like it's shifting or breathing, and a child's change in viewing angle makes it worse.

I've been running a small version of this experiment on myself. We keep a night light in the master bedroom, and I'll often wake well before dawn while it's still black outside. Things in the shadows seem to move, or they refuse to resolve into anything I recognize. My husband's clothes draped over the bedpost, or the covers heaped at the foot of the bed, turn into something else entirely. It's startlingly easy to not know what I'm looking at, when in daylight I'd name it instantly. One morning it was a goblin with glinting eyes. Another time a big male pig stretched out with two ears twitching. More than once I've put my hand out to touch the thing, just to settle for myself what it actually is.

Related