Are Churches Ice-o-lating (Not Just Isolating) New Members?

Think about what happens in a typical worship service. The liturgy, the choir, the scripture readings, the paid musicians. All of it can quietly narrow the circle of who gets to take part and how. Who decides what counts as meaningful worship, and who is left watching from a pew?

Can ordinary members stand up and pray out loud about their own struggles, the troubles of the world, the things God has done in their lives? In plenty of congregations the elders are still all men. There are rules, spoken or unspoken, about who may speak and what topics are allowed, often nothing outside doctrine and the Bible. And the gifts of the Spirit: are people encouraged to use them openly, or are those moments kept behind closed doors?

A related question is whether personal spiritual growth gets real support, not only inside the building and the study groups but in the rest of a person's week.

Then there are the newcomers. When a visitor or a prospective member walks in, does anyone notice? Watch how the regulars behave. Are the greetings genuinely warm, or does a new face get the silent treatment until they feel frozen out and quietly decide not to come back?

I have seen members cluster into their familiar little knots and talk among themselves while someone standing nearby, someone who also has something to say, goes unnoticed. And the children, who are supposed to be the future of the whole thing, sometimes get treated as a nuisance. Their parents end up scolded for failing to keep them still and silent and more or less out of sight.

Worship and fellowship ought to feel welcoming to everyone who shows up, member or not. The church is not a private club reserved for the handful who believe correctly, worship correctly, and imagine themselves somehow clean of sin, past, present, and still to come.

When longtime parishioners give the cold shoulder, the damage is not limited to outsiders. Current members feel it too, and that chill does nothing to carry the message of God's love any further than the parking lot. It is a strange habit, picking apart the faults of other people while quietly letting yourself off the hook.

No sin should be placed beyond the reach of forgiveness. Remember who Jesus sat with and blessed: prostitutes, tax collectors, the people everyone else had written off.

A service should leave you charged up rather than worn down. It should deepen love, renew faith, and send you back out the door ready to walk where Christ walked. Going to church ought to be something you look forward to, a place where you feel wanted and accepted, where a visitor is seen as a gift and an opportunity rather than a complication, a chance for the congregation to notice a need and meet it.

So ask yourself what an atheist sees when they look at a church like the first kind. If they see coldness and rejection, can you really say they have it wrong? What picture of Bible-loving Christians are we handing them? Hatred or love. Acceptance or rejection. A grim performance or actual joy.

With thanks to Bible teacher Joyce Meyer for the inspiration, and to the groups where I have known what loving, joyful fellowship actually feels like.

Related